# Newborn Circumcision: Benefits, Risks, Aftercare

> What Dr. Collin Bennett would go over with parents before a newborn circumcision: the decision, benefits, risks, pain control, the steps and aftercare.

Source: https://www.collinbennett.com/procedure-newborn-circumcision  
Peak Health, PLLC (Colorado Springs, CO) is not open yet and is not seeing patients. To hear first, join the waitlist at https://www.collinbennett.com/#waitlist. General education, not medical advice.

---

Procedure guide

# Newborn circumcision: what parents should know before, during and after

The benefits, risks, pain control and aftercare I'd go over with you before circumcising your son, and what to know if you decide not to.

Written by [Collin R. Bennett, MD](https://www.collinbennett.com/about), board-certified family physician. Updated November 15, 2026.

The short answer

- Circumcision is a choice, not a medical requirement. The major medical groups say the health benefits outweigh the risks, but not by enough to recommend it for every boy, so the decision belongs to parents.
- When it's done in the newborn period with numbing medicine, complications are uncommon, about 4 in 1,000, and most are minor bleeding. Healing takes about 7 to 10 days with petroleum jelly at each diaper change.

Circumcision is the removal of the foreskin, the fold of skin that covers the tip of the penis. Families choose it, or choose against it, for medical, religious, cultural and personal reasons. My job isn't to make the decision for you. It's to give you the facts without pressure, answer your questions, and, if you choose it, do it safely and with real pain control.

**4 in 1,000**newborn circumcisions have a complication, most often minor bleeding

**~100**circumcisions prevent one urinary tract infection in the first year

**7–10 days**typical healing time

Education, not a consent form

This guide explains what a consent visit covers. It doesn't replace the conversation and signed form before your son's procedure, or advice about his own health.

## The decision

The American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Academy of Family Physicians, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and the CDC all recognize health benefits from newborn circumcision. None of them recommends it for every boy. Their shared position is that parents should get unbiased information and decide what's right for their family, and that the procedure should be available to those who want it.

|  | Circumcising | Not circumcising |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Urinary tract infections | Less common in the first year, though they're uncommon either way | About 1 in 100 boys has one in the first year |
| Later infections | Lower risk of HIV and some other sexually transmitted infections in adulthood | Condoms and vaccines protect well regardless |
| Foreskin problems | Prevents a tight foreskin (phimosis) and infections under it | Most boys never have a problem; a few need treatment or circumcision later |
| Penile cancer | Lower risk, though this cancer is rare | Rare either way |
| Risks of the procedure | Bleeding, infection and other complications in about 4 in 1,000 | None |
| Daily care | Petroleum jelly for a week or so, then normal washing | Normal washing. Never force the foreskin back; it separates on its own over years |

## Who it's for

- **Healthy, full-term newborns** who are at least 12 hours old, are feeding well and have urinated normally.
- **Babies in the first weeks of life.** The procedure is simplest and safest early. Complications are 10 to 20 times more common when it's done in older boys, who also usually need general anesthesia.

## Who should wait, or see a specialist

- **A difference in the anatomy of the penis,** such as a urinary opening on the underside (hypospadias), a curved penis (chordee), a twisted or webbed penis, or a penis hidden by the skin around it. The foreskin may be needed for a repair later, so these babies see a pediatric urologist first.
- **A bleeding disorder in the baby or the family,** such as hemophilia.
- **A baby who is premature, ill, jaundiced or in the intensive care unit.** It can wait until he's healthy.
- **A baby who didn't get the vitamin K shot at birth,** since vitamin K helps blood clot and these babies may bleed longer.

## Benefits and risks

### Benefits

Fewer urinary tract infections in infancy. Lower lifetime risk of HIV, some other sexually transmitted infections and penile cancer. No chance of a tight or infected foreskin later. A 2017 review of the research concluded that the benefits outweigh the risks.

### Common risks

Brief pain, which numbing medicine greatly reduces. Fussiness for a day. Minor oozing of blood, the most common complication. Swelling and a yellowish film on the tip while it heals, which is normal.

### Less common risks

Bleeding that needs pressure, a dressing or a stitch. Infection. Too little or too much skin removed. Skin sticking back onto the tip (adhesions). Narrowing of the urinary opening months later, which petroleum jelly during healing helps prevent.

### Rare risks

Injury to the tip of the penis or the urinary passage. Scarring or a poor cosmetic result that needs a second procedure. A reaction to the numbing medicine.

Pain control isn't optional

Newborns feel pain. I'd use numbing medicine for every circumcision: an injection of lidocaine at the base of the penis, which works better than numbing cream alone. A pacifier dipped in sugar water and snug swaddling of the upper body add comfort. Research shows the combination works best.

## The three methods

## Alternatives

- **Not circumcising.** This is a healthy choice. Wash the outside with soap and water, and don't pull the foreskin back. It loosens naturally, often not until age 5 or later, and after that he can learn to rinse under it.
- **Waiting.** Circumcision can be done later for a medical reason or by choice, but it's a bigger operation with a higher complication rate.
- **A ritual circumcision,** such as a bris, performed by someone trained in your faith tradition, such as a mohel.

## Step by step

1. **Check**I examine your son to be sure his anatomy is normal and he's healthy, confirm he had his vitamin K shot, answer your questions, and you sign consent.
2. **Comfort**He's swaddled from the waist up on a padded board with his legs held gently, and given a pacifier with sugar water. Feeding him shortly beforehand is fine.
3. **Numb**The skin is cleaned, and lidocaine is injected at the base of the penis with a tiny needle. We wait about five minutes for it to work.
4. **Separate**The foreskin is gently freed from the tip of the penis, which lets me check the anatomy once more before going further.
5. **Remove**The device is placed to protect the tip, and the foreskin is removed. With a clamp, this takes a few minutes. With a Plastibell, the ring is tied on and stays in place.
6. **Dress**Petroleum jelly and a small piece of gauze go over the tip, then a loose diaper. You can hold and feed him right away.

## Aftercare

The short version

A big dab of petroleum jelly on the tip at every diaper change, loose diapers, and sponge baths until it heals. A yellow film is normal. Bleeding bigger than a quarter is not.

- **Petroleum jelly:** put a generous amount on the tip, or on the front of the diaper, at every change for 7 to 10 days. It keeps the healing skin from sticking to the diaper.
- **The gauze** usually falls off by itself in the first day. If it's stuck, soak it with warm water and ease it off.
- **What's normal:** redness and swelling for a few days, a few drops of blood in the diaper, and a soft yellowish film on the tip. The film is healing tissue, not pus. Don't wipe it off.
- **Cleaning:** rinse with warm water at diaper changes. Skip wipes on the area until it's healed. Sponge baths only for the first week.
- **Diapers:** fasten them loosely.
- **Fussiness** is usual for the first day. Holding, feeding and swaddling help most. Ask me before giving any medicine to a newborn.
- **Plastibell:** no dressing is needed. The ring falls off by itself, usually in 5 to 7 days. Don't pull on it.
- **Follow-up:** I'd see him again in 3 to 5 days to check healing.
- **Later on:** once healed, gently push back any skin at the base of the tip when you bathe him, so it doesn't stick.

## When to call

- Bleeding that keeps coming, or a spot of blood in the diaper larger than a quarter. Hold firm, gentle pressure with gauze and call right away.
- No wet diaper within 8 hours of the procedure, or a weak, dribbling stream.
- Redness or swelling that's spreading or getting worse after day 3, pus, or a bad smell.
- A fever of 100.4°F (38°C) or higher. In a baby under 2 months, any fever needs to be seen the same day.
- The tip of the penis looks dark blue or black.
- A Plastibell ring that has slipped down onto the shaft, or that hasn't fallen off after 10 days.

Which procedures Peak Health offers in the office will be confirmed before opening. You can see the full list on the [Services page](https://www.collinbennett.com/services#procedures), and the rest of these guides in the [procedure guides](https://www.collinbennett.com/procedures) library.

Sources: Omole F, Smith W, Carter-Wicker K. Newborn circumcision techniques. *American Family Physician*. 2020;101(11):680–685. [aafp.org](https://www.aafp.org/pubs/afp/issues/2020/0601/p680.html). American Academy of Pediatrics Task Force on Circumcision. Circumcision policy statement. *Pediatrics*. 2012;130(3):585–586. American Academy of Pediatrics Task Force on Circumcision. Male circumcision (technical report). *Pediatrics*. 2012;130(3):e756–e785.

## Keep reading

[See every procedure guide →](https://www.collinbennett.com/procedures)

[GuideIs DPC worth it for a family?An honest way to decide with your own numbers.](https://www.collinbennett.com/is-dpc-worth-it-for-families)[Procedure guideNumbing medicine and nerve blocks: what to know before, during and afterLidocaine, longer-acting numbing medicine and nerve blocks: how they work, how long they last, how the shot is made less painful, the real risks and what to do afterward.](https://www.collinbennett.com/procedure-nerve-blocks)
