Peak Health opens in Colorado Springs when Dr. Bennett's Army service ends. Join the waitlist to hear first.Opening after Dr. Bennett's Army service endsQuestions? collinrbennettmd@gmail.com
Peak Health logo

Health note

Hydrocolloid bandages: a better way to heal road rash

"Let it air out" is old advice. Scrapes heal faster, and hurt less, when they're kept covered and moist.

The short answer

  • A hydrocolloid bandage seals a clean scrape and turns the wound's own fluid into a moist gel. Small studies show scrapes heal faster and hurt less this way than when they're left to dry out and scab.
  • Clean the scrape well first, then leave the bandage on for several days. Don't use one on a wound that's infected, deep, dirty or from a bite.

I went down on a recent ride and came home with road rash. Instead of gauze and tape, I cleaned it well, covered it with hydrocolloid bandages and left them alone. My heal time was about half of what I expected. That's one rider's experience, not a study, but it matches what the research on these bandages has shown for decades. Here is what they are, what the evidence says, and how I'd use them.

14 of 16scrapes under a hydrocolloid had fully closed by day 14 in a lab study
0 of 16matching scrapes left uncovered had fully closed by day 14
5.6 vs 8.9days to heal in injured cyclists, hydrocolloid versus paraffin gauze

What a hydrocolloid bandage is

A hydrocolloid bandage has two layers. The outside is a thin, flexible, waterproof film. The inside is a sticky layer filled with gel-forming particles. When the bandage sits over a scrape, those particles soak up the fluid the wound weeps and swell into a soft, white gel. That white bubble is the bandage working. It isn't pus.

How a hydrocolloid bandage works on a scrape Two side views of skin with a shallow scrape. On the left, the scrape is left open to the air: a hard, dry scab forms on top, and new skin cells have to grow underneath it. On the right, a hydrocolloid bandage covers the scrape. Its waterproof outer film keeps water and germs out. Its inner layer soaks up fluid from the wound and swells into a soft white gel, which keeps the surface moist so new skin cells can move straight across. Left open to the airUnder a hydrocolloid bandage A hard, dry scab forms. New skin has to grow in underneath it,and the scab cracks when you move. Waterproof film keeps water and germs out. Fluid turns the padinto a soft white gel. The surface stays moist, so new skincan move straight across. Deeper skinDeeper skin
Figure. A scrape left open to dry compared with one under a hydrocolloid bandage. Diagram by Peak Health.

You'll find them sold as Band-Aid Hydro Seal, Compeed and DuoDERM, and as small "pimple patches." The two I'd suggest are on the Products page: a large size for scrapes and road rash, and blister cushions for heels and toes.

Why moist beats dry

For generations, the advice was to let a scrape dry out and scab. In 1962, a researcher named George Winter tested that idea. He made shallow wounds in the skin of young pigs, left half open to the air and covered the other half with a film to keep them moist. The covered wounds grew new skin faster. A scab, it turns out, is a barrier that new skin cells have to tunnel under. On a moist surface, they can move straight across.

A covered wound also hurts less, because the exposed nerve endings aren't drying out or rubbing on clothing, and the bandage doesn't rip off new skin when it's changed the way dry gauze does.

What the studies show

StudyWhoWhat they found
Beam, 200816 healthy adults, each given four identical scrapes on the lower leg in a labBy day 14, 14 of the 16 scrapes under a hydrocolloid had fully closed. So had 10 under a clear film and 11 under a hydrogel. None of the uncovered scrapes had.
Hermans, 199147 cyclists with abrasionsScrapes healed in 5.6 days under a hydrocolloid and 8.9 days under paraffin gauze. More of the hydrocolloid group were free of pain, and none of their scrapes became infected.
Heffernan and Martin, 199496 emergency department patients with cuts, scrapes and small surgical woundsHealing time was similar to a standard non-stick dressing, but patients had less pain, took fewer painkillers and could shower and stay active.

How strong is the evidence?

Modest. These studies are small and most are decades old. In the lab study, the person judging the wounds knew which bandage was used. The main review of hydrocolloids for fresh wounds was paid for by a bandage maker and wasn't a formal pooled analysis. Not every study found faster healing. The most consistent finding is less pain. So I'd say this with confidence: covered and moist is better than open and dry, and a hydrocolloid is a convenient way to do it.

How I'd use one on road rash

  1. WashThis is the step that matters most. Rinse with a lot of clean water. Tap water or the water in your bottle is fine. Gently work out every bit of grit and gravel with a clean, soft cloth or sponge. Dirt left in a scrape can cause infection and can leave a permanent dark stain in the skin.
  2. BlotHold gentle pressure with clean gauze. Hydrocolloids don't stick to a wound that's weeping heavily, so for a large, wet scrape, I'd use a non-stick pad for the first day or two and switch once it settles.
  3. DryThe bandage needs dry, clean skin to stick to. Skip ointment underneath. It keeps the bandage from sealing.
  4. CoverPick a bandage big enough to reach past the scrape on every side. Warm it between your hands, press it on and smooth the edges down.
  5. LeaveIt can stay on for several days, through showers. A white bubble will form over the scrape. Change the bandage when fluid leaks out, the edges peel up or the bubble reaches the edge.
  6. RemoveStretch it sideways along the skin instead of pulling straight up. The new skin underneath will be pink and thin. Protect it with sunscreen for the next few months so it doesn't darken.

When not to use one

  • A wound that looks infected: spreading redness, warmth, swelling, pus, a bad smell or fever. Sealing in an infection makes it worse.
  • Dirt or gravel you can't get out. It needs to be cleaned properly first, sometimes with numbing medicine.
  • Deep or gaping cuts, which may need stitches, and puncture wounds.
  • Animal or human bites.
  • Burns with blisters, unless a doctor has looked at them.
  • Fragile skin, where the adhesive could tear it when the bandage comes off.
  • Diabetes or poor circulation, for any wound on the feet or lower legs. Have it checked first.

When to be seen

  • The scrape is large, on your face, or over a joint and limiting how it moves.
  • You can't get it clean.
  • Bleeding doesn't stop with 10 minutes of firm pressure.
  • Redness is spreading, pain is getting worse after the first two days, or you have a fever.
  • You hit your head, or something else hurts more than the skin does.
  • Your tetanus shot isn't current. A clean, minor wound calls for a booster if your last one was more than 10 years ago. A dirty or deeper wound calls for one if it's been more than 5 years.

Sources: Beam JW. Occlusive dressings and the healing of standardized abrasions. Journal of Athletic Training. 2008;43(6):600–607. Hermans MHE. Hydrocolloid dressing versus tulle gauze in the treatment of abrasions in cyclists. International Journal of Sports Medicine. 1991;12(6):581–584, with results as summarized in Thomas S. Hydrocolloid dressings in the management of acute wounds: a review of the literature. International Wound Journal. 2008;5(5):602–613. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. Heffernan A, Martin AJ. A comparison of a modified form of Granuflex (Granuflex Extra Thin) and a conventional dressing in the management of lacerations, abrasions and minor operation wounds in an accident and emergency department. Journal of Accident and Emergency Medicine. 1994;11(4):227–230. Winter GD. Formation of the scab and the rate of epithelization of superficial wounds in the skin of the young domestic pig. Nature. 1962;193:293–294. Palfreeman R. Management of traumatic skin wounds in professional road cyclists. Aspetar Sports Medicine Journal. 2016;5. aspetar.com. Forsch RT, Little SH, Williams C. Laceration repair: a practical approach. American Family Physician. 2017;95(10):628–636. aafp.org.

Join the waitlist

Peak Health is not open yet. It opens for direct primary care in Colorado Springs after Dr. Bennett's Army service ends. People on the waitlist hear first and are offered membership first.

No payment and no commitment.

Please do not enter any medical information in this form. Privacy

Join the waitlist