Chronic management
Thyroid disease: what your TSH means and how I'd treat it
The symptoms of an underactive and an overactive thyroid, what the blood tests mean, how to take thyroid medicine so it actually works, and how the treatments for Graves disease compare.

The short answer
- A TSH blood test is the first test for thyroid disease. A high TSH usually means an underactive thyroid (hypothyroidism) and a low TSH usually means an overactive one (hyperthyroidism); symptoms alone can't make the diagnosis.
- Hypothyroidism is treated with a daily levothyroxine pill taken 30 to 60 minutes before eating, with a TSH recheck 6 to 8 weeks after any dose change. Graves disease is treated with methimazole, radioactive iodine or surgery.
Your thyroid is a small, butterfly-shaped gland at the front of your neck. It makes the hormone that sets your body's pace: heart rate, energy, temperature, digestion and more. Your pituitary gland, at the base of the brain, watches the level and sends out TSH (thyroid-stimulating hormone) to push the thyroid harder or ease off. That feedback loop is why TSH is the single most useful thyroid test: when the thyroid is slow, TSH climbs; when it's overactive, TSH drops.
Education, not a diagnosis
This guide explains what I'd go over at a visit about thyroid disease. It doesn't replace an evaluation, or advice about your own medicine. Don't change a thyroid dose on your own.
The signs
Both conditions creep up slowly, and many of the symptoms are common in people with normal thyroids, which is why a blood test, not a symptom list, makes the diagnosis.
| Underactive (hypothyroidism) | Overactive (hyperthyroidism) | |
|---|---|---|
| Energy | Tired, sluggish, slowed thinking | Tired, yet nervous, with trouble sleeping |
| Weight | Weight gain | Weight loss despite a bigger appetite |
| Temperature | Always cold | Sweaty, can't tolerate heat |
| Heart | Slow heart rate | Fast or irregular heartbeat |
| Gut | Constipation | Frequent bowel movements |
| Skin, hair, body | Dry skin, thinning hair, muscle and joint aches | Shaky hands, muscle weakness, a swelling in the neck (goiter) |
| Mood and periods | Depression, heavy or irregular periods, fertility problems | Nervousness, irritability, period and fertility problems |
Women are much more likely than men to develop either condition, and both are more common after 60. In older adults, an overactive thyroid can look like depression or dementia instead.
The tests, and what the numbers mean
- TSH: the first test. The usual normal range runs from about 0.4 to 4.0 or 4.5 mIU/L, and each lab sets its own. A high TSH points to an underactive thyroid; a low TSH points to an overactive one.
- Free T4: the thyroid hormone itself. It tells us how far off things are. A high TSH with a normal free T4 is called subclinical hypothyroidism.
- Antibodies: TPO antibodies point to Hashimoto's disease. TSH receptor antibodies diagnose Graves disease, and they're a more cost-effective first step than a scan.
- A thyroid uptake scan: shows the pattern of how the gland takes up iodine, which sorts out the cause of an overactive thyroid when the antibodies don't.
Tell me about biotin before any blood test. The FDA has warned that biotin supplements, common in hair, skin and nail products, can cause falsely high or falsely low results on some lab tests, including hormone tests.
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force found there isn't enough evidence to screen adults who have no symptoms and aren't pregnant. I'd test anyone with symptoms, and people at higher risk, such as those with type 1 diabetes or taking amiodarone or lithium.
Underactive thyroid: hypothyroidism
The most common cause is Hashimoto's disease, an autoimmune condition in which the immune system slowly wears down the thyroid. The treatment is simple and very effective: levothyroxine, a pill identical to the hormone a healthy thyroid makes.
Taking levothyroxine so it works
- Same time, empty stomach: once a day, 30 to 60 minutes before eating.
- Keep 4 hours away from: calcium, iron, antacids, proton pump inhibitors (such as omeprazole) and some cholesterol and weight medicines. They block absorption.
- Some foods raise the dose you need: walnuts, fiber, soy flour and grapefruit juice among them. Consistency matters more than avoidance.
- Starting dose: for most adults under 60, a full dose based on weight (1.5 to 1.8 mcg per kg a day). For people 60 and older or with heart disease, I'd start low, usually 25 to 50 mcg, and build up.
- Recheck: TSH every 6 to 8 weeks, adjusting in small steps, until it's in range. Then every 6 to 12 months.
- Not recommended: T3 (liothyronine), alone or added to levothyroxine, and desiccated "natural" thyroid. The evidence supports levothyroxine alone, and the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists doesn't recommend desiccated thyroid.
Subclinical hypothyroidism
A mildly high TSH with a normal T4 is common and often doesn't need a pill. Outside of pregnancy, I'd treat when TSH is above 10 or TPO antibodies are positive, and otherwise recheck. In adults 65 and older with a TSH under 10, treatment can do more harm than good.
Pregnancy
Untreated hypothyroidism in pregnancy can affect both mother and baby. Thyroid medicine is safe in pregnancy, and many women need a higher dose, so call as soon as you know you're pregnant.
Overactive thyroid: hyperthyroidism and Graves disease
Graves disease is the most common cause. Antibodies switch on the thyroid's TSH receptor and it runs nonstop. It's about 4 times more common in women than men. About 1 in 4 people with Graves develop thyroid eye disease, with bulging, gritty or irritated eyes, and it's more common in people who smoke. Other causes include overactive thyroid nodules, inflammation of the thyroid (thyroiditis), too much iodine, and too high a dose of thyroid medicine.
| How it works | Good to know | |
|---|---|---|
| Beta-blocker | Calms a racing heart and shaky hands, often within hours | Treats symptoms only; it doesn't lower hormone levels |
| Methimazole | A daily pill that slows hormone production | Can bring Graves into remission, usually over 1 to 2 years; can be used long term |
| Radioactive iodine | A single drink or capsule that the thyroid absorbs, slowly shutting it down | Fixes hyperthyroidism in more than 90% of people with Graves; most then need a daily thyroid pill. Not used in pregnancy or breastfeeding |
| Surgery | Removes all or part of the thyroid | Best for a large goiter pressing on the neck, or pregnancy when pills can't be used |
In early pregnancy, a different antithyroid pill, propylthiouracil (PTU), is often used instead of methimazole. Untreated hyperthyroidism isn't harmless: it can cause an irregular heartbeat that leads to clots, stroke or heart failure, plus bone thinning and fertility problems.
What I'd do for everyone
- Skip kelp, seaweed snacks and iodine supplements if you have Hashimoto's or Graves. Large amounts of iodine can make either one worse. Ask before using cough syrups or multivitamins with iodine.
- Don't smoke, especially with Graves, where it raises the risk of eye disease.
- Bring every supplement to your visit, especially biotin, calcium and iron.
Common side effects, and how to handle them
- Levothyroxine: at the right dose it's essentially the hormone your body should be making. Too high a dose causes a fast or irregular heartbeat, chest pain and bone loss over time, which is why we check TSH rather than guess.
- Methimazole: rash and itching are the most common. The serious one is a sudden drop in white blood cells (agranulocytosis), in about 1 in 500 to 1,000 people. If you get a fever or sore throat, stop the pill and call me the same day for a blood count. Rarely it affects the liver: call for belly pain or yellow skin or eyes.
- Radioactive iodine: most people become underactive within about a year, which is expected and treated with a daily pill.
What a visit looks like
- HistorySymptoms, weight, periods, family history, medicines and supplements.
- ExamHeart rate, blood pressure, the thyroid itself, eyes, skin and reflexes.
- LabsTSH first, then free T4 and antibodies as needed.
- PlanTreatment matched to the cause, your age, and plans for pregnancy.
- RecheckTSH 6 to 8 weeks after any change, then every 6 to 12 months once stable.
When to call
- Call 911 for chest pain, fainting, or a racing heart with shortness of breath or confusion.
- Call me the same day for a fever or sore throat while taking methimazole, or yellowing skin or eyes.
- Call me soon if you become pregnant while on thyroid medicine, notice a lump or swelling in your neck, or have trouble swallowing.
Common questions
What is a normal TSH level?
The usual normal range for TSH runs from about 0.4 to 4.0 or 4.5 mIU/L, and each lab sets its own range. A high TSH usually means an underactive thyroid, and a low TSH usually means an overactive one.
When should I take levothyroxine?
Take it once a day, 30 to 60 minutes before eating, and keep it 4 hours away from calcium, iron, antacids and proton pump inhibitors, which block absorption.
How long after changing my thyroid dose should I recheck TSH?
About 6 to 8 weeks after starting or changing a levothyroxine dose. Once TSH is in range, it's usually rechecked every 6 to 12 months.
Does subclinical hypothyroidism need treatment?
Often not. Outside of pregnancy, treatment is generally recommended when TSH is above 10 or TPO antibodies are positive, and in adults 65 and older with a TSH under 10, treatment can do more harm than good.
What are the treatments for Graves disease?
Methimazole pills, radioactive iodine, or surgery to remove the thyroid, often with a beta-blocker at first to calm a racing heart. Radioactive iodine fixes hyperthyroidism in more than 90% of people with Graves, and most then need a daily thyroid pill.
Can biotin affect thyroid blood tests?
Yes. The FDA has warned that biotin supplements can cause falsely high or falsely low results on some lab tests, including hormone tests, so tell your doctor if you take it before blood work.
Sources: Wilson SA, Stem LA, Bruehlman RD. Hypothyroidism: diagnosis and treatment. Am Fam Physician. 2021;103(10):605–613. aafp.org. Mounsey A, Paulus R, Roten W. Hyperthyroidism: diagnosis and treatment. Am Fam Physician. 2025;112(2):146–152. aafp.org. National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases. Hypothyroidism (underactive thyroid) and Hyperthyroidism (overactive thyroid). niddk.nih.gov, niddk.nih.gov. American Thyroid Association. Clinical Thyroidology for Patients: anti-thyroid medication and agranulocytosis. thyroid.org. US Food and Drug Administration. Biotin may interfere with lab tests, safety communication, November 2017, updated November 2019, reported by Drugs.com.
Join the waitlist
Peak Health is not open yet. It opens for direct primary care in Colorado Springs after Dr. Bennett's Army service ends. People on the waitlist hear first and are offered membership first.
No payment and no commitment.
