Peak Health opens in Colorado Springs when Dr. Bennett's Army service ends. Join the waitlist to hear first.Opening after Dr. Bennett's Army service endsQuestions? collinrbennettmd@gmail.com
Peak Health logo

Procedure guide

Setting a broken bone or dislocation: what to know before, during and after

Which fractures and dislocations I'd treat in the office, which I'd send to a surgeon, and the risks, steps and recovery I'd go over with you first.

The short answer

  • Many broken bones are stable and well lined up, and heal with a splint or cast alone. Some need to be set first, which means numbing the area and guiding the bone or joint back into place by hand.
  • Most simple fractures heal in 4 to 8 weeks. Open fractures, breaks into a joint, and any injury with numbness or poor blood flow need a surgeon, sometimes urgently.

A fall on an outstretched hand, a rolled ankle, a shoulder that pops out on the ski hill: these are everyday injuries in an active town. Family physicians manage a large share of fractures from start to finish. The first job is deciding which kind of injury it is. Most simple breaks need only the right splint or cast. Some need to be set, called a reduction. And some need a surgeon.

4–8 weekstypical healing time for most simple fractures
3 weeksin a removable splint is enough for a child's buckle fracture of the wrist
Up to 90%of active people under 25 dislocate the same shoulder again

Education, not a consent form

This guide explains what a consent visit covers. It doesn't replace the conversation and signed form before your own procedure, or advice about your own injury. For a bone poking through the skin, a limb that's cold, blue or numb, or a possible neck or back injury, call 911.

What "setting" means

When a bone breaks, the pieces may stay lined up or shift out of place. When a joint dislocates, the two bones that meet there come apart. Setting, or closed reduction, means moving them back into position from the outside, with no cut in the skin. The area is numbed, steady traction relaxes the muscles, and the bone or joint is guided back into place. X-rays before and after confirm the position, and a splint or cast holds it there while it heals.

Setting a wrist fracture Two side views of a forearm and hand. On the left, before setting, the forearm bone is broken near the wrist and the short end piece is tilted upward and shifted out of line. One arrow shows steady pulling on the hand and another shows gentle pressure pushing the tilted piece back down. On the right, after setting, the bone is back in a straight line with only a thin fracture line showing, and a splint runs along the underside of the forearm and hand to hold it. BeforeAfter Gentle pressureSteady pull SplintFracture line the broken end is tilted and out of line the bone is straight again on the tilted piece relaxes the muscles holds the position while the bone heals Forearm bone (radius)
Figure. Setting a wrist fracture. Before, the broken end of the forearm bone is tilted and shifted. Steady traction and gentle pressure bring it back in line, and a splint holds it there. Diagram by Peak Health.
Usual office treatmentWhen it needs a surgeon
Buckle fracture of the wrist (children)Removable splint for about 3 weeks; no setting neededRarely
Wrist fracture (distal radius)Splint, then a short-arm cast for 3 to 6 weeks if well lined upBreak into the joint, shortening of more than 2 mm, tilt of 10 degrees or more, or it won't stay in place
Collarbone fractureSling for comfort for 2 to 6 weeks if the ends haven't shiftedWidely shifted ends, especially in very active people; skin tenting
Finger and toe fracturesBuddy taping or a small splint; simple setting after numbingBreaks into the joint, rotation of the finger, or open wounds
Shoulder dislocationGuiding the joint back in, then a sling for 2 to 4 weeksA fracture with it, repeat dislocations, or a first dislocation in an active person under 25
Pulled elbow in a toddler (nursemaid's elbow)A quick, gentle maneuver; usually no splintRarely

Who it's for

  • Closed fractures, meaning the skin is intact, that are stable or can be lined up and held with a splint or cast.
  • Simple dislocations of the shoulder, finger, toe or kneecap, with normal feeling and blood flow beyond the injury.
  • Injuries seen early. Setting is easiest in the first hours, before swelling and muscle spasm build.

Who needs a surgeon or the emergency room

  • Open fractures, where bone has broken the skin. These need the operating room and antibiotics.
  • Numbness, a cold or pale hand or foot, or a weak pulse beyond the injury. This is an emergency.
  • Breaks that extend into a joint, or are in many pieces, badly shifted or unstable.
  • Hip, thigh, spine and pelvis fractures, and most fractures around the elbow and ankle that have shifted.
  • Fractures through a child's growth plate that have shifted.
  • Severe pain and tightness that keep building, which can mean dangerous pressure in the muscles (compartment syndrome).

Benefits and risks

Benefits

Bones that are lined up heal straighter and work better. A reduced joint stops hurting almost at once. Treating it in the office avoids an emergency room visit for many simple injuries.

Common risks

Pain during the numbing and the reduction. Swelling and bruising. Stiffness and some muscle loss from being immobilized, which improve with rehab.

Less common risks

The bone slipping out of position again, which is why follow-up X-rays matter. Not being able to set it in the office, meaning a referral. A shoulder that dislocates again.

Rare risks

Injury to a nerve or blood vessel. Carpal tunnel symptoms after a wrist fracture, which affect up to a quarter of people. Healing in a poor position, or not healing. Compartment syndrome.

Follow-up X-rays are part of the treatment

A fracture that looks perfect on day one can drift in the first week or two as swelling goes down. If X-rays at first look normal but I still suspect a break, I'd splint it and repeat them in 7 to 14 days. Please don't skip the recheck.

Alternatives

  • A splint or cast alone, when the bone is already well lined up. This is the right treatment for most simple fractures.
  • Surgery with pins, plates or screws, when a fracture can't be held in a good position from the outside.
  • Accepting some angle, which is often fine in young children, whose bones straighten as they grow, and in less active adults for some fractures.

Step by step

  1. CheckI ask how it happened, look for swelling and deformity, and check feeling, movement and blood flow beyond the injury. X-rays show the fracture and its position.
  2. DecideWe look at the X-rays together and decide between a splint alone, setting it in the office, or sending you to a surgeon. If we're setting it, you sign consent.
  3. NumbNumbing medicine goes into the fracture site, into the joint, or around a nearby nerve. See the guide to numbing and nerve blocks.
  4. SetSteady traction relaxes the muscles, then the bone or joint is guided back into place. For a shoulder, gentle positioning and slow movement often do it without force.
  5. HoldA splint goes on while I hold the position. A sling supports a shoulder or collarbone.
  6. RecheckNew X-rays confirm the position, and I recheck feeling and blood flow before you go home.

Recovery

The short version

Elevate it, ice it, keep the splint dry, come back for your recheck, and start moving again when I say it's time.

  • The first 2 to 3 days: keep the injury raised above the level of your heart as much as you can, and ice it over the splint for 15 to 30 minutes at a time.
  • Pain: acetaminophen or ibuprofen is usually enough once the bone is stable. Pain that keeps getting worse is a warning sign, not something to push through.
  • Recheck within 1 to 2 weeks, often with an X-ray. A splint is usually changed to a cast once the swelling settles.
  • Move what isn't immobilized. Wiggle your fingers or toes often, and keep the shoulder and elbow moving when an arm is in a cast.
  • Rehab starts once the bone is healed enough: range of motion first, then strength. After a shoulder dislocation, that means a sling for 2 to 4 weeks, then guided exercises.
  • Return to sport when you're pain-free with full motion and strength. We'd plan it together.

When to call

  • Pain that's getting worse instead of better, especially with a feeling of tightness.
  • Numbness, tingling or a hand or foot that's cold, pale or blue.
  • Fingers or toes that you can't move, or that hurt badly when stretched.
  • A splint or cast that feels too tight, gets soaked or cracks.
  • A joint that slips out again.

Which procedures Peak Health offers in the office will be confirmed before opening. You can see the full list on the Services page, and the rest of these guides in the procedure guides library.

Sources: Patel DS, Statuta SM, Ahmed N. Common fractures of the radius and ulna. American Family Physician. 2021;103(6):345–354. aafp.org. Simon LM, Nguyen V, Ezinwa NM. Acute shoulder injuries in adults. American Family Physician. 2023;107(5):503–512. aafp.org. Boyd AS, Benjamin HJ, Asplund C. Principles of casting and splinting. American Family Physician. 2009;79(1):16–22. aafp.org.

Join the waitlist

Peak Health is not open yet. It opens for direct primary care in Colorado Springs after Dr. Bennett's Army service ends. People on the waitlist hear first and are offered membership first.

No payment and no commitment.

Please do not enter any medical information in this form. Privacy

Join the waitlist